Wednesday, May 28, 2008

‘Either Maoists or Army will take over'

http://www.kantipuronline.com/kolnews.php?&nid=148139

When the whole world is curiously watching how Nepal's 240-year-old Shah dynasty will formally end just two days from now, the Post caught up with Kamal Thapa, a political leader who played a major role during King Gyanendra's direct rule, to discuss the possible repercussions. Outspoken Thapa, who was also the Home Minister in the government formed after the February 1 royal takeover, has been standing by the side of the monarchy since the beginning.

Speaking with Puran P Bista and Kamal Raj Sigdel of the Post, he warns that the impact of the parties' decision to end the monarchy will be devastating. Thapa suggests that the parties implement their decision to establish a republic only after drafting a new constitution if they do not want the Maoists or the Nepal Army to take over.

Excerpts:

Q: How do you assess the current political developments?

Thapa: We are on the verge of a historic change. If we succeeded in properly managing it to move through the transition, we could achieve the objective of peace, stability and prosperity. But if we fail, it will only make matter worse.

Q: What sort of political exercise do you see on the eve of a historic CA meeting?

Thapa: The political parties, instead of dealing with the real issues, are bickering on petty things. They have been hankering after posts and portfolios rather than working on the real issues. This is not the first instance they acted like this. If we look at the trend of their actions in the past two years, whenever they have come across any issue of national interest, they have never held discussions. But important decisions have been taken in haste. Their main attention is always on power-sharing.

The way the political development is unraveling, I mean if this is the indication of the future trend, I see — the writing is on the wall — there will be only two things: Either the extreme left will take over the state power, or there will be another round of confrontation. Except these two, I don’t see a third possibility.

Q: The first meeting of the CA is formally putting an end to the institution of monarchy. What will be the repercussions of such a declaration?

Thapa: They are trying to implement this in haste and in an artificial manner. I don’t think this will yield any positive result because to make Nepal a republic is not only to change a government and a prime minister. It means an end of an era. It is not only the matter of a 240-year old institution; in Nepal’s context, it will be an end of a thousand years’ history. This will bring about a sweeping change in the social, cultural and religious values and norms.

The way the political parties are dealing with such serious issues in haste, and the way they are trying to do it artificially … they are in fact trying to implement that in an artificial environment … this will not yield good results. The decision will create a big void, and that will have a big impact on security organs of the state, in religious, social and cultural contexts, values and norms, administrative mechanisms, and similarly in the foreign policy. In the eventuality of the parties failing to manage it properly, a political disaster is inevitable.

Q: What do you mean by managing it “properly” when the parties enjoy the people’s mandate to declare Nepal a republic?

Thapa: First, the parties have not been able to establish valid reasons to end the institution of monarchy. In fact the efforts to end it began as per the desire of foreign powers and ultra-left Maoists’ strategic objective. Therefore, no reason whatsoever has been established to justify that move.

Second, the way it is being implemented is totally unjust. Even to impeach a head of government, let alone to sack, we need sufficient political and constitutional grounds. Had they held a referendum on the future of monarchy, a constitutional and legitimate process would have been established.

The CA election was not only about republic versus monarchy. In a country like Nepal where the majority of the people are illiterate, they voted mainly on the basis of the parties or political identifications. And the way it is being said, that the first meeting will decide, is very artificial.
There is a provision of two-thirds majority to amend the constitution. But to end the institution of monarchy — which has such a long historical background, which is deeply rooted in our socio-cultural values and norms, and until of late which was regarded as a symbol of national unity — just a simple majority is said to be needed. It is supposed to be decided on the next two-three days, but till today, nothing has been discussed upon — the procedures, the methods for the same.

So everything is being done in haste, and there are not enough reasons established to take such a decision. Therefore, I say this will create a void.

Q: You spoke of basis or enough reasons for declaring Nepal a republic. Aren’t the results of the CA polls the basis?

Thapa: Of course, the political parties came up with a republic agenda, they won a majority, but the parties themselves have not said it clearly what the crime of the monarch is. The monarchy is soon to be a victim of conspiracy of foreign powers, and strategic objective of the extreme left forces of this country. This is very unfortunate.

Those who like to see the monarchy existing in any form are not in a condition to speak openly. Of course, the monarchy might have taken some controversial decisions in the past, but those decisions cannot alone be the reasons for ending an institution that holds a long history. It has made several important contributions too — be it the unification of the country or in establishing democracy in the 1950; be it in heading nationalist movements or establishing Nepal’s independent identity in the world. The parties are ignorant of such contributions while taking political decisions about the institution. What I want to say is, agreed, they have won, but they have not made it clear why the monarchy should be abolished?

Q: Given such “unjust” decisions, how will the political parties be able to implement them? The monarchy cannot be ignored as one of the forces. How will the king react?

Thapa: You see the only force of the monarchy is the people. But the people who want monarchy are disorganized. They are rendered voiceless. They are helpless and confined to their homes. I believe there are still a large number of people who want monarchy. I don’t know how many in number they are. But there is a large section of people that wants monarchy. Today, if any one dares to speak in favor of the monarchy, s/he incurs a great risk of attack on his family. Therefore, they are mute.

And those who had to protect this institution have unfortunately betrayed and in that they have also betrayed the history of Nepal. They should have done it [protected the king].

Q: You spoke of another kind of betrayal. It is also rumored that there was an understanding among the political parties and the monarchy before the end of the April movement and that the parties are now betraying the monarchy.

Thapa: Yes. That is all clear. We know that there has been some sort of understanding between the agitating political parties and the palace. The statement read by the king was virtually drafted by the leaders of the political parties; the king simply read that out. It has been proved by the events that followed the announcement.

The parliament passed a historical document on May 18, 2006, which the leading media and the political parties termed it as Nepal’s Magna Carta. Where is that document now? Have we forgotten that? If that was a Magna Carta, what is the crime of the institution, particularly in the days after that agreement?

Q: What sort of scenario do you foresee right after the first meeting of the CA?

Thapa: I cannot say what the king will do. Nor can I speak on behalf of the king. As a political activist and an independent observer, what I say is if we look at the tradition of the monarchy, it never wanted to come in confrontation with the people, be it in 2036 BS (1980), 2046 BS (1990) or 2063 BS (2006). So I don’t think that monarchy will enter into a confrontation with the political forces.

But by default, the void created [by the decision of the first CA meeting] will have an immediate impact on the security forces of Nepal, then on the social, cultural and religious fabrics of the society, then on the administration and on the foreign policy. The impact will be so big that I don’t think the current political leadership will be able to manage it. In that situation one of two things that will happen: either a complete takeover by the Maoists or another round of confrontation.

Q: Does that “another round of confrontation” mean the takeover by the army?

Thapa: Yes, that comes as the second option. After confrontation I don’t rule out the possibility of one of the two taking over. But what will happen after the emotional bond between the army and the monarchy abruptly breaks? Nobody has thought about that. What will happen to the morale of the institution which is regarded as the last fortress of the country’ national security? Declaring Nepal a republic is not a big thing but the void created will be devastating.

Q: What sort of void are you talking about?

Thapa: What will be the scenario of Nepal’s national politics after May 28th? Nobody knows. So I have been reiterating that let us not do things in haste. First, we cannot ignore the fact. Whether we like it or not there are major political parties who are in favor of republic. Another established fact is that they have a majority. So, it is not that they cannot decide. They have the capacity. But there should be proper study on the impact of the implementation of their decision. If that is necessary to implement, let’s do it at the end, when we will have a new constitution.

We have not even started the constitution drafting process. But, on the other hand, we are going to take such a major decision. To make a new constitution is not just to prepare a document. There is no political understanding and consensus among the major political parties about the guiding philosophy of the constitution.

First, there should be a common and basic idea, upon which the constitution is written. We have political parties which are polls apart ideologically. Second, there are several sensitive issues — right to self-determination, federalism, army integration, etc— about which there are serious differences among political forces. If we cannot sort them out, writing a new constitution may not be possible. There are examples. So, what I suggest is first let us complete the drafting of the constitution. But at a time when there is uncertainty over whether a constitution will ever be written or not, why are the parties in haste and are hell bent on taking such a major decision?
Have we thought about what will happen after the end of the monarchy … the impact on the security forces … in their morale? When that confrontation occurs, they could be used by any one for someone’s advantage. They can be used as a weapon; that may invite a political disaster.
Q: Do you think the army has been committed to Comprehensive Peace Agreement? Has the army been playing any assertive role?

Thapa: I still don’t want to comment on that. I sill want to give a benefit of doubt to that institution, but the way the events will develop … what will the army decide … the people are watching.

Q: What is Prachanda up to?

Thapa: He has been saying that he has not come to transform himself as the NC and the UML, that they have never accepted parliamentary form of democracy. In a real sense, the Maoists have not renounced violence; they have said that both the peace process and the People’s War are the two sides of the same coin. These are not my words, they are on records. So what the Maoists want can be understood by their own words and deeds.

Maybe we can use the institution of monarchy even in drafting a new constitution; we can do that by consensus. What I say is the king cannot expect the monarchy of the past; the right and authority to govern rests on the representatives of the people. The king also should accept this. And the political parties, too, have a possibility to use the institution for a peaceful transition. So let’s first draft the constitution, and, if the representatives deem it necessary, the decision about the institution of monarchy could be taken during that process.

Posted on: 2008-05-25 20:06:00 (Server Time)

Nepal: Winds of change blow king from power

By Colin Freeman in Kathmandu

Last Updated: 9:06AM BST 25/05/2008

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/nepal/2022073/Nepal-Winds-of-change-in-blow-king-from-power.html

King Gyanendra, members of whose Shah dynasty have been worshipped as real-life Hindu deities for much of their 240-year rule, is no longer popular with his 28 million subjects, and today Mr Shakiya does not stock so much as a tea towel with his majesty's face on it.
"It's true, artists have not been making statues of the current king," admitted Mr Shakiya, whose only remaining royal merchandise is an elderly pair of statues of the king's late predecessor, Birendra. "Some of the stationery shops might sell a few postcards of him, but I'm not sure."

As of this week, however, such postcards may acquire a new value as collectors' items, when Nepal's newly elected government meets on Wednesday to begin formal proceedings to abolish the monarchy.

King Gyanendra, 60, faces being kicked out of his red‑walled palace in central Kathmandu and reduced to the state of a commoner – a dramatic fall from grace for a man whose family once ruled by divine right.

To add insult to injury, a government committee is investigating how to divide up large shares of
the royal estate, which includes palaces, hotels, and fleets of Mercedes vehicles, among his subjects.

Yet the transformation of the world's last Hindu monarchy into a secular republic is the casualty of a political movement that, elsewhere at least, has itself become a dying creed.

Leading the calls for the king's demise is the country's growing Maoist movement, no longer in fashion in neighbouring China, but thriving in modern Nepal thanks to discontent at the grinding poverty that two centuries of monarchy largely failed to address.

A former guerrilla movement which fought a brutal insurgency costing 15,000 lives in the past decade, the Maoists have used both bullet and ballot to make their way into power, winning more than a third of the seats in last month's elections to become the dominant political bloc in the national assembly.

The movement's leader, a moustachioed former teacher who goes under the nom de guerre of Prachanda, or the Fierce One, claims to be a modern Maoist, saying he believes in multi-party democracy and even "bourgeois capitalism". But his group draws the line at Nepal's royal family, whose wealth has come to symbolise the Himalayan nation's inequality and backwardness.

The only question now is whether the king stays on as an ordinary citizen, heads abroad for comfortable exile or, as some hardline Maoists would like, goes somewhere more uncomfortable.

"The king is a criminal who should go to jail," said Chandra Bahadur Thapa, 32, a former Maoist insurgent who runs the Kathmandu branch of the movement's Young Communist League, where Prachanda's picture is displayed in a gallery of Leftist "heroes" alongside Stalin, Lenin and Marx.
"Nepal is rich in resources, yet we are among the poorest people in the world. I hold the royal family responsible for that."

But in a country where monarchy is shrouded in superstition, there are explanations for the fall of the House of Shah that lie beyond the worldly rationales of Marxist didactics.

Some link it to an ancient curse which declared that their rule would wither after 10 generations, a prediction that acquired horrible prescience in 2001, when the king's Eton-educated brother, Birendra – the 10th Shah – was gunned down along with his wife and 10 other family members.
The culprit was none other than his own son, the drink- and drug-addled crown prince Dipendra, who killed first his family and then himself after a dispute over whom he could marry.

For many, the massacre demonstrated just how dysfunctional the monarchy had become.
Gyanendra, previously a successful businessman, vowed to modernise when he took over, yet in many ways his reign has proved just as self-destructive.

He in effect signed his own abolition decree in 2005, when he dismissed the elected government and temporarily resumed absolute rule in a bid to crush the Maoist threat. The move backfired, delivering the Maoists a propaganda coup.

Even more unpopular is his son and heir, Crown Prince Paras, a playboy who is alleged to have killed a popular Nepalese singer while drunk at the wheel of his vehicle. But will Gyanendra's departure make Nepal a better place?

The nation's other political parties, which have performed with mixed results since absolute rule was formally ended in 1990, have largely backed the Maoist calls for his ousting, although this was partly because it was one of the group's conditions for laying down arms.

Yet the king also has his supporters, who claim that the damaging rumours which circulate in Kathmandu's bazaars – that he has pinched nine tons of gold from state coffers, for example, and that he owes the government £500,000 for the palace utility bills – are almost wholly untrue.
"It's just Leftist propaganda," said Kamal Thapa, 53, the head of the royalist National Democrat Party.

"The king did not impose autocratic rule, it was a response to the strength of the Maoist terrorist campaign. And the incident with Prince Paras was just an accident. But even if he has made mistakes, that is no excuse for removing a 200-year-old institution."

Monarchy may be lofty, he adds, but by rising above Nepal's innumerable different ethnic groups – at least 24 different languages are spoken within its mountain valleys – it has also bound the country together and allowed it to grow independently from its giant neighbours, India and China.

"The monarchy and an independent Nepal are entwined together, and the country could easily disintegrate if it goes."

Such views are not confined to wealthy types like Mr Thapa, whose daughter's wedding last month was attended by the king. Surveys suggest that most ordinary Nepalis back the institution of monarchy – if not the monarch himself.

Many fear it is the thin end of the political wedge for the Maoists, who may prove as dictatorial as any divine ruler.

"The Maoists say they will deliver equality, but nobody really believes them," said Kumari Bhising, 36, a streetside herb seller.

Nepalis also worry about the Maoists' Young Communist League, whose "morality patrols" and unionising activities often seem little more than fronts for racketeering and thuggery.

"Many of them operate like the Mafia, no matter what their leaders say," said Pravin Jung Mayamajhi, 36, a Kathmandu restaurateur. "I don't think you should rip the royal family out like that just because of one bad apple. Look at what happened in Russia when they did that."
But revolution seems inevitable, and on the currency at least, the order of "off with the king's head" is well under way.

Crisp new 1,000-rupee notes are being printed, minus the royal profile, although a faint outline of his face is just visible on the watermark, which the Royal Mint – or, rather, plain old Mint – has deemed too expensive to replace. In time, even that pale image of Gyanendra may disappear forever.

Nepal King to address the nation

TGW http://telegraphnepal.com/news_det.php?news_id=3473

Nepal’s sidelined monarch Gyanendra whose fate the CA first meet is to decide on May 28, 2008 is preparing to forward his conditions to the government of Nepal prior to quitting the Royal Palace of Nepal once and for all.

Latest reports on King Gyanendra who is currently staying at the Nagarjun Palace- some eight kilometers north-west of the capital have it that he is holding serious discussions with his close aides as regards the final proposal to be pushed to the perusal of the government of Nepal, which will mainly focus on the security concerns of his family members after the Royalty vacates the Narayan Hit Royal Palace.

King Gyanendra will return tomorrow May 26, 2008 to the Narayan Hit Palace, say reports adding, that he is scheduled to hold a serious but presumably the last discussion with the Prime Minister of Nepal, Mr. Girija Prasad Koirala on May 27, 2008.

How King Gyanendra will convince the Prime Minister as regards his “security concerns” is yet not known.

“Nevertheless, King Gyanendra will address the nation before quitting the royal palace”, say sources close to the royal palace in Nepal.

Insiders at the Royal Palace presume that the King in his last message to the nation will suggest the new managers of the republican order to safeguard the national sovereignty and territorial integrity in the absence of the “institution of the monarchy”.
2008-05-25 08:30:21

Sunday, May 25, 2008

सङ्कटभित्रको सङ्कट ध्रुवहरि अधिकारी

सन् १९३६ -विसं १९९३/९४) मा बेलायतमाथि 'गद्दी-त्याग' सङ्कट आइपर्‍यो । अङ्ग्रेजहरू त्यस घटनालाई 'एब्डीकेसन क्राइसिस्'को प्रसङ्गबाट सम्झन्छन् । भएको के थियो भने युवक राजा एर्डवर्ड आठौ“ले एउटी त्यस्ती अमेरकिी नारीसित बिहेको इच्छा गरे, जसले विगतमा दर्ुइपल्ट बिहे गरसिकेकी थिइन् ।


राजाको त्यस प्रस्तावलाई प्रधानमन्त्री स्टान्ली बाल्डवीनको सरकारले अनुमति दिन मानेन । महिनौ“सम्म धार्मिक, राजनीतिक र सामाजिक मान्यताका कुराहरू र्सार्वजनिक बहसमा आए । राजालाई आफ्नो विचार त्याग्न प्रेरति गरयिो । तर, उनले हठ छोडेनन् । सरकारले पनि उनको योजनालाई स्वीकृति दिएन । कि गद्दी त्याग्नुपर्ने भयो, कि मनपरेकी स्त्री छोड्नुपर्ने परििस्थति सिर्जना भयो । अन्ततोगत्वा राजाले गद्दी त्यागकै घोषणा गरे १० डिसेम्बर १९३६ का दिन । खाली राजगद्दीमा राजकुमार अर्ल्बर्टलाई राजा जर्ज छैटौ“का रूपमा आरोहण गराएर सङ्कट सुल्झाइयो । अहिलेकी गद्दीनसिन महारानी एलिजाबेथ द्वितीया तिनै राजा जर्ज छैटौ“की जेठी छोरी हुन् ।



यतिखेरको नेपालको सङ्कटको प्रमुख कारक पनि राजा नै हुन्, उनकै हठ र महत्त्वाकाङ्क्षा हो । गणतन्त्रका नारा, 'नारायणहिटी खाली गर' भन्ने दबाब, गद्दी छोड्ने मागलगायतका सान्दर्भिक विषयहरूको जरो राजहठ नै हो भन्ने तथ्य जगजाहेर छ । दम्भ, अहङ्कार र आक्रोशका परण्िाति एक-एक गरेर क्रमैसित दृश्यपटलमा आएका हुन् । एकाएक यो अवस्था निर्माण भएको किमार्थ होइन । २०४६ सालको जनआन्दोलनपछि संवैधानिक राजा हुन राजी भएका वीरेन्द्रका भाइ हुनुभन्दा ०१७ सालको फौजी काण्डमार्फ सक्रिय हुन अघि सरेका महेन्द्रको छोरो हुने महत्त्वाकाङ्क्षाले ज्ञानेन्द्रलाई बिगारेको निष्कर्षउनकै निकटस्थहरूले समेत निकालेका छन् ।


देश ०४६ सालबाट लामो फड्को मारेर डेढ दशक अगाडि पुग्दा ज्ञानेन्द्रले भने ०१७ को शैलीमा सैनिक हस्तक्ष्ँेपद्वारा देशका तात्कालिक राजनीतिक, आर्थिक चुनौतीहरूको सामना गर्न सकिन्छ भन्ठाने र सरासर गलत बाटो समाते । ०५९ असोज र ०६१ माघका कदम त्यसै प्रवृत्तिका जल्दाबल्दा प्रमाण हुन् । अनि, बेलायतका राजा एर्डवर्ड आठौ“लाई नारी-मोहले कर्तव्यबोधबाट च्यूत गर्राई दिग्भ्रमित तुल्याएझै“ राजा ज्ञानेन्द्रलाई पुत्रमोहले धृतराष्ट्र बनायो । र, कालक्रममा बाबुछोरा नै अलोकप्रिय हुन पुगे ।


राजसंस्थाको सामन्ती स्वरूप त्यसै पनि लोकप्रिय थिएन, त्यसमाथि जनसरोकारका मामिलाप्रतिको लगातारको उपेक्षाभावले राजाप्रतिको जनधारणा नकारात्मक हु“दै गयो । निर्धन देशको राज्यकोषलाई निजी ढुकुटीसरह खोलेर जथाभावी ढङ्गले भत्ता, भोज र भ्रमणहरूमा खर्च गर्ने सिलसिलाले जनस्तरमा पहिलेदेखि व्याप्त उदासीनता र आक्रोश विरोधमा परण्िात भएको हो । प्रस्टै छ, परििस्थति क्रमशः गरेर ब्रि्रेको हो, एकाएक अप्ठ्यारोपन आएको होइन । सच्याउने, सुधार गर्ने अवसर गुमाउ“दै गएपछि नै वातावरण धमिलिएको हो । आन्तरकि बलमा भन्दा बाहिरी आडमा टिक्ने रणनीति राजनीतिक दलहरूलाई काम नलागेजस्तै राजाका लागि पनि र्सार्थक वा निर्ण्ाायक हुन नसक्ने तथ्य पटकपटकका घटनाक्रमले पुष्टि गरेका छन् ।


उक्साउने रणनीति


नेपालको भलो नचाहनेले यस देशलाई सध“ै अस्िथर राख्न खोज्छन् । 'प्रभाव क्षेत्र'का नाममा हस्तक्षेपका लागि मलिलो ठाउ“ बनाउन खोज्छन् । यस क्रममा तिनले राजालाई पार्टर्ीीरुद्ध र पार्टर्ीीलाई राजाविरुद्ध उक्साउने रणनीति अख्तियार गर्न सक्छन्, गरअिाएकै छन् । तर, यस्तो कुरो ठम्याइसकेपछि पनि बाहिरी शक्तिले फालेको बल्छीमा जानाजान किन पर्नु - वार्ता, सम्झौताद्वारा मुलुकमै मामिला सुल्झाएको भए त्यस बखतका सात दलले दिल्ली गएर माओवादीसित हात मिलाउनुपर्ने थिएन ।



बाहिरी 'मध्यस्थ' अथवा 'भूमिका' आवश्यक पर्ने थिएन । र, 'निरङ्कुश राजतन्त्र'को अन्त्य गराउने योजना खेस्राकै स्तरमा तामेलीमा जाने थियो । अर्को कोणबाट हर्ेदा यसमा राजनीतिक पार्टर्ीीको पनि दोष देखिएला तर उदार भएर पहल गर्ने दायित्व त राजाको थियो र कैफियत त्यही“ भइदियो ।


०६५ सालको आरम्भमा आइपुग्दा नेपालको राजतन्त्रले विडम्बनायुक्त संयोग देख्दैछ ः ००७ सालमा बाजे त्रिभुवनको अनुपस्िथतिमा राजतन्त्रको निरन्तरता कायम राख्न उभ्याइएका नाबालिग ज्ञानेन्द्र नै ५८ वर्षछि राजतन्त्रको क्रमभङ्ग हुन लागेको स्िथति हर्ेर्दैछन्, बेहोर्दैछन् । राजा हुनाले अझै दैवीशक्तिको आशा-भरोसा हुनु र्सवथा स्वाभाविक हो । हुने हुनामी त टारेर र्टर्दैन †


राजाका अगाडि धेरै विकल्प देखि“दैनन् । ०६३ वैशाख ११ गतेको घोषणापछि उपलब्ध भएजति विकल्प पनि अब छैनन् । यसबीचमा गिरजिाप्रसाद कोइरालाले राजा र युवराज दुवैले 'स्टेप डाउन' गरििदए सानु राजा -बेबी किङ्)को बन्दोबस्त गर्न सकिने सङ्केत र्सार्वजनिक गरेका थिए । त्यो एउटा राम्रँे विकल्प हुनसक्थ्यो, आलङ्कारकि राजतन्त्रको सिलसिला अघि बढाउन । र्'र्सवनासे समुत्पन्ने अर्द्ध त्वजति पण्डितः' भन्ने नीति वचन छ । यसको आशय बुझेर आफूले -र, छोराले) गद्दीत्याग गरेर भए पनि नेपालमा राजसंस्थाको सान्दर्भिकता जोगाउन सक्ने थिए ।


टाढा जानैपर्दैन, भुटानकै राजा जिग्मेसिङ्गे वाङ्चुकले गद्दीत्यागको ताजा उदाहरण प्रस्तुत गरेका छन् । छोरालाई गद्दी दिए र आफू अवकाशको जीवन ढुक्कसित बिताइरहेको देखिन्छ । बेलाबखत छोरालाई परामर्श दि“दा हुन् । तर, लाग्छ- ज्ञानेन्द्रलाई यस्तो प्रस्ताव आकर्ष लागेन । परामर्शदाताहरूको सुझावमा सके राजाको यस्तो सोच बनेको छ ः राजतन्त्र नै नराखे कुरै सकियो, राख्ने हो भनेचाहि“ गद्दीमा कसले बस्न पाउ“छ भनेर अरूले तोक्न मिल्दैन । यस्तो तर्क आफ्नो ठाउ“मा ठीक होला तर चेतनशील नेपाली समाजले स्वीकार गर्न सक्दैन । यो घामजत्तिकै र्छलङ्ग तथ्य हो ।


नेपाली सेनाको आड र आधार राजतन्त्रका सर्न्दर्भमा बरोबर चर्चामा आउने अर्को पक्ष्ँ हो । परम्पराको मात्र कुरो गर्दा एक किसिमको अवधारणा बन्ला तर तथ्यगत विवेचना गर्दा सेनाको नेतृत्व यथार्थपरक दृष्टिकोण बनाउन सामान्यतः सक्षम नै देखिन्छ । उदाहरण ०६३ सालकै घटना हुनसक्छ । सैनिक कारबाहीबाट मात्र राजनीतिक समस्याको हल निस्कन सक्दैन भनी उतिखेर हात झिक्ने 'शाही' सेनाले अहिलेको परविर्तित स्िथतिमा आएर राजाका पक्षमा सैनिक हस्तक्षेप कसरी गर्ला - र, अन्तर्रर्ााट्रय समुदायले के आधारमा त्यस्ता कार्यलाई मान्यता देला - हो, दरबारमा करबि तीन हजारको सङ्ख्यामा रहेका सैनिकले माओवादी पक्षबाट एक्कासि आक्रमण भइहालेमा जवाफी कारबाहीमा हतियार चलाउन सक्छन् । तर, त्यो सानो टुकडीले तख्तापलट गर्ने व्रि्रँेही शक्तिको रूप लिने सम्भावना न्यून छ । सीमित समयको प्रतिरक्षा कार्य -डिफेन्सिभ एक्सन)सम्म हुनसक्छ । ठूलै रूप लिन लाग्यो भने बाहिरी शक्तिको सहमति वा भूमिका भएको अनुमान गर्नुपर्ने हुन्छ ।


राजाको हैसियतले ज्ञानेन्द्रले गरेका कार्यहरू लोकसम्मति अनुकूल थिएनन्, समयसापेक्ष रहेनन् भन्ने कुरामा सन्देह रहेन । राजा आफै“, राजसंस्था र मुलुक अनिश्चयको भुमरीमा पर्न गएकोमा पनि विवाद छैन । आन्दोलनलाई अघि बढाउनमा ती गलत नीति र कार्यहरूको सहयोगी भूमिका रह्यो भनेर प्रचण्डले ज्ञानेन्द्रलाई धन्यवाद दिने गरेको प्रसङ्ग पुरानो होइन । तर, समय सधै“ एकनास रह“दैन । सके 'जेठ १५ गतेअगावै नारायणहिटी खाली गर्नू' भन्ने माओवादी सन्देशको तत्काल सकारात्मक प्रत्युत्तर नआउनुको पछाडि यस्तै परविर्तित सर्न्दर्भसित गा“सिएका कारण हुन सक्छन् ।


आखिर २ सय ४० वर्षो इतिहास भएको राजसंस्थाको अस्ितत्वसित जोडिएको प्रश्न छ, त्यससित जोडिएका मान्यता र परम्पराहरू छन् । डेरामै बसेको मानिसले त घर खाली गराउन मनासिबमाफिकको समय पाउ“छ भने राजगद्दी -दरबार) छोड्नेबारे बीचबीचै आएको उर्दीको पालना तुरुन्तै भइहाल्छ भन्ने अपेक्षा गर्नु उचित हुन्न । संविधानसभा गठन नहु“दै र सरकार गठन नहु“दै जारी गरएिका आदेश-निर्देशको वैधानिकता र आधिकारकिता कसरी स्थापित हुने हो - प्रतिस्पर्धात्मक राजनीतिमा प्रवेश गरेको शक्ति -माओवादी) र यसको नेतृत्वपङ्क्तिले विधिको शासन र विवेकको प्रयोगमा अभ्यस्त हुने हो भने बेलैमा यस्ता कुराहरूबारे हेक्का राख्नु आवश्यक छ ।


खतरनाक दृष्टान्त


राजतन्त्रको अन्त्यपछिको रत्तिmताको पर्ूर्ति कसले गर्छ र कति सहज ढङ् गबाट हुन्छ, त्यसबारे ढुक्क हुन नसकेर नै नेपाली जनतामाझबाट तर्क र आशङ्काका तरङ्गहरू निस्केका हुन् । छरछिमेकका घटनाक्रमले असुरक्षाको वातावरण बनाएको हो । सिक्किममा राजा थिए र देश थियो । तर, पछि अनेक षड्यन्त्रको तानाबाना बुनियो र त्यहा“का राजा -चोग्याल) अलोकप्रिय हुने गतिविधिमा लागे । पछि गएर राजतन्त्रकै अन्त्य गरयिो । राजतन्त्र अन्त्य गरेपछि सिक्किमलाई भारतमा विलय गराइएको घटना पुरानो होइन । विलय गराउने कार्य ठीक थिएन भनेर इन्दिरा गान्धीको आलोचना गरे तापनि पछिल्ला प्रधानमन्त्री मोरारजी देसाइ भइसकेको विलयलाई उल्टाउन सकि“दैन भनेर टकटकिए । उत्तरको चीनले सुरुमा सिक्किमलाई भारतमा गाभेको कुरालाई मान्यता दिएन तर सन् २००३ मा आएर आफ्नो अडानलाई त्याग्यो र अटलविहारी वाजपेयी चीन भ्रमणमा आएको अवसर पारी भारतीय कब्जालाई मान्यता दियो ।


चीनको यस नीतिले दक्षिण एसियामा पारेको नकारात्मक असर एउटा छुट्टै विवेचनाको विषय हुनसक्छ । मुख्य कुरो, दक्षिणको छिमेकीको आशय र हस्तक्ष्ँेपकारी व्यवहार हो । अरूलाई खाने बाघले आफूलाई पनि खान सक्छ भन्ने आशङ्का निराधार पनि होइन । नेपालको आफ्नो चिनारी, आफ्नोपन झल्काउने आधारहरू मास्नु, मासिन दिनु भनेको अन्ततोगत्वा यसको अस्ितत्व लोप हुन दिनु हो । यसबारे सजग र चनाखो हुनु आफूलाई देशभक्त शक्ति सम्झनेहरूको टड्कारो कर्तव्य हो । नेताहरूले सोच्ने कुरो हो, देश नै नरहे तिनीहरूको राजनीतिले खेल्ने थलो कहा“ पाउ“छ -


राजतन्त्रको अन्त्य गरििदएपछि राज्य कब्जा गर्न सजिलो हु“दोरहेछ भन्ने अर्को उदाहरण अमेरकिामा भेटिन्छ । हाल संयुक्त राज्य अमेरकिाको ५०औ“ राज्यका रूपमा चिनिने राज्य हवाई -टापू) साविकमा राजतन्त्रात्मक स्वतन्त्र देश थियो । अमेरकिी शासकहरूले पहिले त्यस देशको राजतन्त्र समाप्त गरििदए र सन् १८९३ मा त्यस देशको अस्ितत्व नै समाप्त पारियो । हवाई अधिराज्यलाई अमेरकिी साम्रँज्यको एउटा अङ्ग तुल्याइयो । त्यस क्रममा अनेक ज्यादती भए, जसबापत एक सय वर्षछि अर्थात् सन् १९९३ मा राष्ट्रपति क्लिन्टनले अमेरकिाका तर्फाट हवाईका जनतासित औपचारकि हिसाबले 'क्ष्ँमायाचना' गरे । हवाई अधिराज्यकी महारानी लिलिओकालानीको सविस्तार उल्लेख भएको क्ष्ँमायाचना प्रस्तावसहित के-कस्तो अवस्थामा त्यहा“ राजतन्त्र मासेर देश नै कब्जा गरयिो, त्यसको विवरण अमेरकिी पत्रिका द नेसनमा भर्खरै -२८ अप्रिल २००८) पनि प्रकाशित भएको छ ।


अन्त्यमा,


राज्यव्यवस्थामा राजनीतिक आरोह-अवरोहका सर्न्दर्भले र्सवाधिक महत्त्व राख्छन् । तर, विधि-विधानका पक्ष्ँहरू पनि उत्तिकै प्रबल हुन्छन् । संवैधानिक कानुनका अध्येता एक मित्रले हालै एउटा प्रश्न गरे, "पशुपतिका मूलभट्ट -पुजारी)को आचरण खराब भयो भने उनलाई कार्यभारमुक्त गरेर अर्को भट्ट नियुक्त गर्ने कि पशुपतिको मन्दिर नै भत्काउने -" अहिलेको यहा“को कार्यशैली मन्दिर नै भत्काउने ढङ्गको छ । होला, खा“टी कम्युनिस्टलाई धर्मकर्मको मतलब रह“दैन । तर, यो देशका सबै बासिन्दा त कम्युनिस्ट होइनन् । र, खा“टी हौ“ भन्ने माओवादीकै नेता बाबुराम भट्टर्राईले चुनावअघि देवताको दर्शन गरी आशर्ीवाद लिएको घटना जनमानसमा ताजै छ ।


अर्को कुरा, चुनावमा माओवादीले जम्मा ३० प्रतिशत मत पाएको समानुपातिकको परण्िाामले देखाएको छ । यसको अर्थ ७० प्रतिशत नेपालीले माओवादीको कार्यसूची -एजेन्डा)लाई सोझै र्समर्थन नगरेको स्िथति छ । माओवादीले यस तथ्यमा निहित सन्देशलाई ठम्याएर पाइला सार्नु उचित हुन्छ । बाटो त अग्रगामी नै लिने हो तर सावधानीका साथ । होसियारीका साथ । संयमित भएर । अन्यथा दलिन बालेर खरानीको खडेरी टार्ने बाटो समातेसरह हुनेछ ।

दर्घटना हुनसक्छ दर्घटना हुनसक्छ

http://www.kantipuronline.com/Nepal/aabaran.php

अहिले पनि राजतन्त्रको वकालत गरिरहेको पार्टर्ीीाप्रपा नेपालका अध्यक्ष कमल थापा राजा र माओवादीबीच सम्भव भए कुनै सहमति गराउन प्रयत्नशील हुनुहुन्छ, भलै त्यस्तो सूत्रधार-भूमिकाको औपचारिक स्वीकारोक्तिचाहि“ उहा“को मुखबाट निस्कन्न ।

राजा र माओवादीबीच तपाईंले कस्तो भूमिका खेल्नुभएको हो -

मैले राजा र माओवादीबीच सन्देश आदानप्रदान गर्ने काम गरेको छैन । माओवादीलगायत विभिन्न दलस“गको मेरो भेटघाट राप्रपा नेपालको अध्यक्षको हैसियतमा भएको हो । संविधानसभा निर्वाचनअघि र पछि पनि राजतन्त्र र गणतन्त्र महत्त्वपर्ूण्ा एजेन्डाका रूपमा रहेको छ । त्यसैले खासगरी माओवादीस“गको कुराकानीका क्रममा मैले हतारमा राजतन्त्रबारे निर्ण्र्ाानगरौ“, संविधानसभाले संविधान निर्माण गरसिकेपछि मात्रै फैसला गर्न उपयुक्त हुन्छ भन्ने धारणा राखेको छु ।

नया“ बन्ने संविधान लागू नहुन्जेल गणतन्त्रको कुरालाई थाती राख्ने भन्न खोज्नुभएको -

हो, निश्चय नै । अहिलेको निर्वाचन परण्िाामबाट प्रस्ट के देखिन्छ भने दलहरूले चाहेको खण्डमा कुनै पनि बेला गणतन्त्रको घोषणा गर्न सक्छन् । तर, संविधानको पहिलो अक्ष्ँर पनि नलेखीकन, भोलिको संवैधानिक व्यवस् था, राज्यप्रणाली, राज्यको संरचनाको टुङ्गो नलगाई लामो ऐतिहासिक पृष्ठभूमि रहेको संस् थालाई हठात् हटाउ“दा सिर्जना हुनेे रत्तिmताका कारण दर्ुघटना पनि हुनसक्छ ।

यसबारे माओवादी नेताहरूको प्रतिक्रिया कस्तो पाउनुभयो -

माओवादीका शर्ीष्ास्थ नेताहरूले नै राजालाई धार्मिक, सांस्कृतिक प्रतीकका रूपमा राख्न सकिने सम्भावना छ भनेर र्सार्वजनिक रूपमा आफ्ना धारणा राखिसक्नुभएको छ । विषयको संवेदनशीलतालाई ध्यानमा राखेर त्यसबारे मैले थप टीकाटिप्पणी गर्नु उपयुक्त हु“दैन । तर, माओवादीहरूमा पहिला जुन किसिमको व्रि्रँेही धारणा थियो, त्यसमा परमिार्जन आएको, जिम्मेवार राजनीतिक शक्तिमा रहनुपर्ने शैली, सोच र व्यावहारकि पक्ष मैले कुराकानीका क्रममा पाएको छु ।

राजाको मुडचाहि“ कस्तो छ -

भेटघाटका क्रममा मैले राजामा एउटा विचित्र किसिमको आत्मविश्वास पाएको छु । र, पटकपटकको भेटमा स्वयम् राजाबाटै म कुनै पनि परििस्थतिमा देश छाडेर जान्न भन्ने अभिव्यक्ति पाएको छु ।
अघि तपाईंले राजसंस्था हटाए दर्ुघटना हुनसक्छ भन्नुभयो, कस्तो दर्ुघटना -

अहिले पनि विभिन्न राजनीतिक शक्तिहरूका बीचमा धेरै ठूलो वैचारकि, सैद्धान्तिक र व्यावहारकि मतभेद कायम छ । यसबाहेक आत्मनिर्ण्र्ााो अधिकार, समग्र मधेस एक प्रदेश, सेना समायोजनजस्ता कैयौ“ यस्ता विषय छन्, यसले विखण्डनका आवाज ल्याउन सक्छ, विदेशीको चलखेल बढाउन सक्छ । दर्ुघटना निम्त्याउन सक्छ । र, संविधान निर्माणको कार्य नै अपर्ूण्ा रहन सक्छ ।

यी विषयस“ग राजतन्त्र रहनु र नरहनुको के सम्बन्ध छ र -

राजतन्त्रको अन्त्यपछि रहने रत्तिmताको प्रत्यक्ष असर नेपालको परम्परागत राज्यका सबै संयन्त्रहरूमा पर्न जान्छ । नेपाली सेनामा त्यसको असर पर्न सक्छ, सुरक्षाका अन्य अङ्गमा त्यसको असर पर्न सक्छ । यसले सङ्र्घष्ा र द्वन्द्वको सम्भावनालाई चर्काउन सक्छ ।

अहिले नेपाली सेना र राजदरबारको सम्बन्धचाहि“ कस्तो रहेको छ -

नेपाली सेनाको जन्म नै शाहवंशीय राजाहरूबाट भएको हो र २ सय ४० वर्षलामो इतिहासका क्रममा ऊ जहिले पनि राजसंस्थाप्रति बफादार रह“दै आएको छ । आफ्नो जन्मदाता भएकाले दरबारस“ग सेनाको गहिरो भावनात्मक सम्बन्ध हुनर्ुपर्छ भन्ने लाग्छ ।

आफ्नो जन्मदातालाई नै हटाइदाखेरि सेनाको प्रतिक्रिया के होला -

सेनाको प्रमुखले नै बारम्बार भन्दै आइरहनुभएको छ कि, नेपाली सेना राष्ट्रिय एकता र अखण्डताको संरक्षणका निमित्त र प्रजातन्त्रप्रति प्रतिबद्ध रहनेछ । राजसंस्थास“ग गहिरो भावनात्मक सम्बन्ध रह“दारह“दै नेपाली सेना परम्परादेखि नै तत्काल कायम रहेको सरकारको नीति-निर्देशन र संविधानबमोजिम सञ्चालन हु“दै आएको छ ।

परम्परागत रूपमा राजालाई राष्ट्रिय एकताको प्रतीक मानिएको अवस्थामा सेना प्रमुखले बार म्बारका सम्बोधनमा राष्ट्रिय एकताको कुरा गरेर राजा नहटाउन साङ्केतिक खबरदारी गरेका हुन् त -

सेना प्रमुखले कुन प्रसङ्गमा त्यो कुरा भन्नुभयो, त्यसको त म जवाफ दिन सक्दिन“ । तर, व्यक्तिगत बुझाइमा राष्ट्रियता र राष्ट्रिय एकताको कुरा गर्दाखेरी परम्परागत रूपमा राजालाई राष्ट्रिय एकताको प्रतीक मानिएको अवस् थामा त्यो पनि त्यस परविेशभित्र परेको हुनर्ुपर्छ भन्ने मेरो मान्यता हो ।

Issues surrounding abolition of monarchy

By BIPIN ADHIKARI

http://www.kantipuronline.com/kolnews.php?&nid=147732
The Kathmandu Post May 22, 2008

With less than a week left for the apparent end of monarchy, the CPN (Maoist) leaders have intensified their demand that King Gyanendra leave the palace well before May 28. This is the fateful date set by Prime Minister Girija Prasad Koirala for the first meeting of the newly elected Constituent Assembly, where he is going to table a motion to abolish monarchy, and lay down the foundation of the 'New Nepal.'

In the first meeting of the Constituent Assembly, Prime Minister Koirala is supposed to invoke Article 159 of the Interim Constitution, which gives him power to table such a motion, and the members of the Assembly are to vote on it according to Article 75. The fathers of the Interim Constitution, who believed that revolutions know no bounds of law, probably thought that the Assembly does not need any governing principles as to how the decision of the House is to be made and implemented.

As such, the existing interim parliament, the unelected members of which are still drawing their remuneration from the national coffer, did not think of the Abolition of Monarchy Act to meet the requirement of the due process. So the decision to be made politically is also likely to be implemented in a most controversial way.

While the Assembly process is yet to begin, the Maoist leaders have already started threatening the king and his family to leave the Narayanhiti palace as fast as possible. They have consistently indicated the possibility of the use of force to get the king out after May 28. Prime Minister Koirala too is on record several times for having said that the king should abdicate, and make the transition smooth. His remarks, although not as bitter as that of the Maoist leaders, also had contents of a veiled threat. While it is not clear why the Maoists want the king to leave the palace, at least a day before, or what political benefits will accrue to them if the king really gratifies them by accepting the request, the issues that involve in this context go beyond. The concern here is emphatically legal.

To a lawyer, it is not understandable how somebody can execute a decree without a court first awarding it. For example, whether a decree is for payment of money or for the recovery of any land or property, it must first be obtained from a law court. Such a decree gives necessary entitlement to the decree-holder to execute the decree against the judgment debtors. Then the execution may be effected by delivery of property, or by attachment and sale, or arrest of the defaulter, or in such other manner as the nature of the relief granted may require. This is what the civil law of Nepal states. Unless it does not apply to King Gyanendra, there is no reason why the rule of law should be parted with like this. Hence, the May 28 process must first be complied with before asking the King to leave the palace.

Again, Narayanhiti is not an illegal possession of the monarch. He is not its illegal occupant. He has every right to stay there until the law of the land is amended and he is deprived of his possession based on a valid piece of law. The legal tradition of this country builds around the principle that possession is 9/10ths of the law — or that one who has physical control of his property is clearly at an advantage should his rightful ownership of the property ever be subject to challenge. Even when a tiny public company is liquidated, it takes months to settle all claims. It is not convincing when the king as an ordinary individual is deprived of this process. It is better for the 'new regime', therefore, to wait for the May 28 process, and follow the legitimate course afterwards so that when they are at low ebbs, the legal system is able to protect their legitimate rights too.

King Charles the First, known as a noted English autocrat, was put on trial in January 1649 and executed following disagreements between him and his rump Parliament controlled by the army. Both sides claimed that they stood for the rule of law. The rump Parliament, with the backing of the army, established a High Court of Justice, where he was charged with high treason 'against the realm of England'.

The only people allowed into Parliament were those who Oliver Cromwell (Prachanda's rightist counterpart by analogy) thought supported the trial of the king. In fact only 68 out of 135 judges turned up for the trial. The public was not allowed into the hall until after the charge had been read out. The king refused to plead guilty, saying that he did not recognize the legality of the High Court in the first place. He said it was established by a Commons purged of dissent, which had never acted as a judicature, and without the House of Lords.

On the scaffold, the man who was to execute Charles refused to do it. So did others. Very quickly, another man and his assistant were found to do the job. His last speech to the crowd was "I have delivered to my conscience; I pray (to) God you do take those courses that are best for the good of the kingdom and (to) your own salvation."

Time changed even if some people were not looking forward to it. When Charles II returned to become King of England in 1660, following a long period of instability, those men who had signed his father's death warrant (and were still alive) were tried as regicides (the murderer of a king) and executed. Everyone associated with the execution except the executioners of Charles was put on trial. These executioners were able to escape as no-one knew who they were. After a struggle for about twenty years between royalists and republicans, monarchy was restored, and the English people again became subjects of the head of the Scottish house of Stuart. The main reason behind it was the unfair trial of Charles I.

In a similar case in Nepal, where it is not an army-supported trial which is involved in the abolition of monarchy, the Assembly should indeed enable the controversial monarch to contest the motion against him in the House, and present his version of the story before the actual voting under Article 75 of the Constitution. It will be too youthful to think that this can any way change the mood of the Assembly, or of the revolution which is making advances.

Nevertheless, the king of Nepal, who is being treated as the principal defendant should have the opportunity to speak to the people who must know what the other side of the story is. In democracy it matters; and it matters in the most powerful sense. The king is not being toppled, he is being laid off. If this is the truth, then the process requires that he must be allowed an adequate opportunity to present his case. Additionally, even if the faulty Constitution is silent on whether the sovereign representatives of the people have the right to caste their vote of conscience on the issue, they should be afforded this opportunity without expressing or implying whips from their parliamentary parties.

Eventually, those who are said to be making history should make it on the strength of self-respect and certain universal values. These values — justice, equality, the rule of law, to mention the most basic ones — need to be protected, no matter who gains from it. It might delay the process a little, but it can surely give a clear outlet to the problem and a firm footing to the democrats.

lawyers_inc_nepal@yahoo.com

Issues surrounding abolition of monarchy

By BIPIN ADHIKARI


http://www.kantipuronline.com/kolnews.php?&nid=147732
The Kathmandu Post May 22, 2008


With less than a week left for the apparent end of monarchy, the CPN (Maoist) leaders have intensified their demand that King Gyanendra leave the palace well before May 28. This is the fateful date set by Prime Minister Girija Prasad Koirala for the first meeting of the newly elected Constituent Assembly, where he is going to table a motion to abolish monarchy, and lay down the foundation of the 'New Nepal.'


In the first meeting of the Constituent Assembly, Prime Minister Koirala is supposed to invoke Article 159 of the Interim Constitution, which gives him power to table such a motion, and the members of the Assembly are to vote on it according to Article 75. The fathers of the Interim Constitution, who believed that revolutions know no bounds of law, probably thought that the Assembly does not need any governing principles as to how the decision of the House is to be made and implemented.


As such, the existing interim parliament, the unelected members of which are still drawing their remuneration from the national coffer, did not think of the Abolition of Monarchy Act to meet the requirement of the due process. So the decision to be made politically is also likely to be implemented in a most controversial way.


While the Assembly process is yet to begin, the Maoist leaders have already started threatening the king and his family to leave the Narayanhiti palace as fast as possible. They have consistently indicated the possibility of the use of force to get the king out after May 28. Prime Minister Koirala too is on record several times for having said that the king should abdicate, and make the transition smooth. His remarks, although not as bitter as that of the Maoist leaders, also had contents of a veiled threat. While it is not clear why the Maoists want the king to leave the palace, at least a day before, or what political benefits will accrue to them if the king really gratifies them by accepting the request, the issues that involve in this context go beyond. The concern here is emphatically legal.


To a lawyer, it is not understandable how somebody can execute a decree without a court first awarding it. For example, whether a decree is for payment of money or for the recovery of any land or property, it must first be obtained from a law court. Such a decree gives necessary entitlement to the decree-holder to execute the decree against the judgment debtors. Then the execution may be effected by delivery of property, or by attachment and sale, or arrest of the defaulter, or in such other manner as the nature of the relief granted may require. This is what the civil law of Nepal states. Unless it does not apply to King Gyanendra, there is no reason why the rule of law should be parted with like this. Hence, the May 28 process must first be complied with before asking the King to leave the palace.


Again, Narayanhiti is not an illegal possession of the monarch. He is not its illegal occupant. He has every right to stay there until the law of the land is amended and he is deprived of his possession based on a valid piece of law. The legal tradition of this country builds around the principle that possession is 9/10ths of the law — or that one who has physical control of his property is clearly at an advantage should his rightful ownership of the property ever be subject to challenge. Even when a tiny public company is liquidated, it takes months to settle all claims. It is not convincing when the king as an ordinary individual is deprived of this process. It is better for the 'new regime', therefore, to wait for the May 28 process, and follow the legitimate course afterwards so that when they are at low ebbs, the legal system is able to protect their legitimate rights too.


King Charles the First, known as a noted English autocrat, was put on trial in January 1649 and executed following disagreements between him and his rump Parliament controlled by the army. Both sides claimed that they stood for the rule of law. The rump Parliament, with the backing of the army, established a High Court of Justice, where he was charged with high treason 'against the realm of England'.


The only people allowed into Parliament were those who Oliver Cromwell (Prachanda's rightist counterpart by analogy) thought supported the trial of the king. In fact only 68 out of 135 judges turned up for the trial. The public was not allowed into the hall until after the charge had been read out. The king refused to plead guilty, saying that he did not recognize the legality of the High Court in the first place. He said it was established by a Commons purged of dissent, which had never acted as a judicature, and without the House of Lords.


On the scaffold, the man who was to execute Charles refused to do it. So did others. Very quickly, another man and his assistant were found to do the job. His last speech to the crowd was "I have delivered to my conscience; I pray (to) God you do take those courses that are best for the good of the kingdom and (to) your own salvation."


Time changed even if some people were not looking forward to it. When Charles II returned to become King of England in 1660, following a long period of instability, those men who had signed his father's death warrant (and were still alive) were tried as regicides (the murderer of a king) and executed. Everyone associated with the execution except the executioners of Charles was put on trial. These executioners were able to escape as no-one knew who they were. After a struggle for about twenty years between royalists and republicans, monarchy was restored, and the English people again became subjects of the head of the Scottish house of Stuart. The main reason behind it was the unfair trial of Charles I.


In a similar case in Nepal, where it is not an army-supported trial which is involved in the abolition of monarchy, the Assembly should indeed enable the controversial monarch to contest the motion against him in the House, and present his version of the story before the actual voting under Article 75 of the Constitution. It will be too youthful to think that this can any way change the mood of the Assembly, or of the revolution which is making advances.


Nevertheless, the king of Nepal, who is being treated as the principal defendant should have the opportunity to speak to the people who must know what the other side of the story is. In democracy it matters; and it matters in the most powerful sense. The king is not being toppled, he is being laid off. If this is the truth, then the process requires that he must be allowed an adequate opportunity to present his case. Additionally, even if the faulty Constitution is silent on whether the sovereign representatives of the people have the right to caste their vote of conscience on the issue, they should be afforded this opportunity without expressing or implying whips from their parliamentary parties.


Eventually, those who are said to be making history should make it on the strength of self-respect and certain universal values. These values — justice, equality, the rule of law, to mention the most basic ones — need to be protected, no matter who gains from it. It might delay the process a little, but it can surely give a clear outlet to the problem and a firm footing to the democrats.
lawyers_inc_nepal@yahoo.com